remakes in goty nominations
Members debate whether ground-up remakes deserve Game of the Year nominations, focusing on Ocarina of Time and Final Fantasy.
- Opinions diverge on whether remakes should qualify for Game of the Year or if separate categories are needed
- Some argue games rebuilt from scratch or drastically altered deserve recognition, citing Final Fantasy
- Critics argue the Ocarina of Time remake is primarily visual updates without enough new content to warrant nomination
- Supporters contend older classics like Ocarina of Time feature new additions and hold equal validity against sequels like GTA 6


