Starship versus SLS viability debate
Members debate Starship versus SLS, highlighting development costs, launch timelines, single points of failure, and payload deployment constraints.
- SLS cost roughly 25 billion dollars, while Starship has cost an unspecified amount exceeding 30 billion dollars
- Rockets like SLS, Vulcan, and New Glenn had successful flights to space prior to Starship completing similar milestones
- Safety concerns include water penetration on Crew-6 heat shields, LOX pipe cracks on Falcon 9, and single points of failure on HLS
- Starship payload deployment door design limits its practical utility primarily to Starlink and specialized satellite deployment


