Skip to main content
Discovery icon for The Dawnless Days Discord server

The Dawnless Days

11,107 Online
84,113 Members
lore-discussion4 people

Christopher Tolkien editing and changes

Christopher Tolkien compiled his father's writing into coherent narratives rather than authoring original works, later expressing regret over certain editorial decisions.

  • The Children of Hurin consists of J.R.R. Tolkien's own writings compiled and edited by Christopher Tolkien into a coherent narrative
  • Christopher contributed extensive analytical notes rather than writing his own narrative fiction
  • Christopher later regretted certain edits, feeling some choices were made hastily, misread his father's intent, or altered details better left untouched
  • Editorial choices regarding Gil-galad's parentage remain debated, though keeping High Kings within Fingolfin's lineage is favored by some readers
Summarized from recent messages, might be inaccurate

More conversations

tdd-chat

Lasgalen archer balance and power

tdd-chat

early Gondor campaign defense strategies

lore-discussion

legitimacy of Silvan Elf kings

Talk, Play, &
Hang Out

Find your space to hang out, discuss the latest updates with the party chat, and see who's down to join your next match.
Get App