Skip to main content
spoiler-discussion3 people

planeswalkers as commanders and lore

Players discuss why Universes Beyond characters are rarely planeswalkers and debate why planeswalkers are restricted as Commanders.

  • Wizards avoided making external or Universes Beyond characters Planeswalkers after AFR backlash confused how external realms fit into Magic's multiverse
  • Treating external planets or dimensions as planes could logically turn every ship crewmember into a planeswalker
  • Allowing all planeswalkers to be Commanders causes balance issues, citing Brawl experiences and cards like Jace, the Mind Sculptor
  • Modal double-faced cards like Valki, God of Lies enable planeswalker commanders that create oppressive play patterns such as land destruction
Summarized from recent messages, might be inaccurate

More conversations

submission-discussions

hybrid mana symbol layout rules

challenge-build-2

designing a sliver commander

casual-build-room-2

designing around Mel's draw ability

casual-build-room-1

designing the hume level mechanic

Talk, Play, &
Hang Out

Find your space to hang out, discuss the latest updates with the party chat, and see who's down to join your next match.
Get App